AllBankingSolutions.com

......our answer to all your banking needs

 

;

BURDEN OF PENSION - GAINS AND LOSSES

[9th Bipartite Settlement for Wage Revision in Banks -Update on ninth Bipartite Settlement Negotiation between IBA and UFBU about Pay / Salary / Wage Revision for PSU Bank Officers / Employees]

by

Rahul Singh

Part I : Minutes of the Discussions Held on 27/11/2009 :

Minutes of the Discussions held on 27th November 2009 between IBA representing the Management of Banks and UFBU consisting of 5 Workmen Unions viz. AIBEA, NCBE, BEFI, INBEF and NOBW and 4 Officers’ Associations viz. AIBOC, AIBOA, INBOC & NOBO on another option to join the pension scheme


The Indian Banks’ Association and the United Forum of Bank Unions (UFBU) entered into a Memorandum of Understanding on 25th February 2008 on various issues. Extending another option for pension to those who did not opt for pension when Bank Employees’ Pension Regulations, 1995 were implemented was one of the issues to be considered. Several rounds of discussions have taken place on the issue. An actuarial valuation of the liability was assessed through two commonly agreed actuaries who identified the total liability for extending another option for pension to non-optees.    On receipt of the actuarial valuation of the liability, several rounds of discussions have taken place between the parties and the following terms have been mutually agreed.


1. Existing employees


(i) The employees who were in service of the Banks as on the date of Pension Regulation ie. 29.9.1995/ 26.3.1996 and continue in service as on the date of settlement/ Joint Note to be signed between the parties, shall be given one more option to join the Pension Scheme.
(ii) The Banks’ contribution to Provident Fund along with interest thereon in respect of those employees who opt for pension shall be transferred to the Pension Funds of the respective Banks.
(iii) The gap in the pension fund identified will be shared between parties as under:
(a) 70% of the gap by the bank.
(b) 30% by the employees who are in service of the bank as on the date of Memorandum of Settlement/ Joint Note to be signed between the parties in this regard. This amount will be recovered from the arrears payable on wage revision.

 

2. Retired Employees


(i) Those employees who were in the service of the bank as on 29.9.1995/ 26.3.1996 who were eligible but, did not opt for pension and retired thereafter shall also be extended the option for joining the Pension Scheme. Towards joining the Pension Scheme they will –
(a) Refund the bank’s contribution to the Provident Fund with interest thereof received by them at the time of retirement.
(b) Contribute to the Pension Fund their share of 30% of the gap in the pension fund identified.


3. The Bank Employees’ Pension Regulations, 1995 will be effective upto 31.3.2010 and cease to apply to any person appointed in the services of banks on or after 1.4.2010.
4. A defined contributory retirement benefit scheme as governed by the “contributory pension scheme introduced for employees of Central Government with effect from 1.1.2004” will be introduced for workmen/officers joining the services of banks on or after 1.4.2010. There shall be no separate contributory provident fund in respect of these workmen/officers.
5. The terms of this minutes will not be applicable to State Bank of India.
6. The Parties will meet on mutually convenient dates to draw out a detailed Memorandum of Settlement/Joint Note in this regard; and appropriate modifications in the Bank Employees’ Pension Regulations will be made following the prescribed procedure in this regard. The parties will endeavour to finalise the Memorandum of Settlement/ Joint Note within a period of ninety days from the date of this minutes.

 

Signed at Mumbai on 27th November 2009
Record Note of the Discussions held on 27th November 2009 between IBA representing the Management of Banks and UFBU consisting of 5 Workmen Unions viz. AIBEA, NCBE, BEFI, INBEF and NOBW and 4 Officers’ Associations viz. AIBOC, AIBOA, INBOC & NOBO on extending another option to join the pension scheme

 

 

Part II : Analysis of the Pension Burden:

 The Indian Banks’ Association and the United Forum of Bank Unions (UFBU) entered into a Memorandum of Understanding on 25th February 2008 on various issues. Extending another option for pension to those who did not opt for pension when Bank Employees’ Pension Regulations, 1995 were implemented was one of the issues to be considered. Several rounds of discussions have taken place on the issue. An actuarial valuation of the liability was assessed through two commonly agreed actuaries who identified the total liability for extending another option for pension to non-optees as under:

Another Option for Pension (Serving Employees)                           (Rupees in Crores)

Total Liability as on 31.3.2008 as per Actuarial Valuation – Joint Exercise 17190.00
PF Accumulation 11532.00
Gap 5658.00
Add 2% of Total Liability for loss/ incomplete data 343.81
Balance 6001.80

Another Option for Pension (Retired  Employees)                           (Rupees in Crores)

Total Liability as on 31.3.2008 4774.29
PF Accumulation to be refunded 1657.79
Balance 3116.50


On receipt of the actuarial valuation of the liability, several rounds of discussions have taken place between the parties and the following terms have been mutually agreed.


1) Existing employees
The employees who were in service of the Banks as on the date of Pension Regulations i.e. 29.9.1995/ 26.3.1996 and continued in service as on the date of settlement/ Joint Note to be signed between the parties, shall be given one more option to join the Pension Scheme.
2) The Banks’ contribution to Provident Fund along with interest thereon in respect of those employees who opt for pension shall be transferred to the Pension Funds of the respective Banks.
3) The gap in the Pension Fund identified (Rs.6001.80 crores) is agreed to be shared between the parties as under:
a) 70% (Rs.4201.26 crores) by the banks.
b) 30% (Rs.1800.54 crores) by all the employees who are in service of the banks as on the date of the Memorandum of Settlement/ Joint Note to be signed between the parties in this regard. This amount will be recovered from the arrears payable on wage revision.


4) Retired Employees
Those employees who were in the service of the bank as on 29.9.1995/ 26.3.1996 who were eligible but, did not opt for pension and retired thereafter shall also be extended the option for joining the Pension Scheme. Towards joining the Pension Scheme they will –
a) Refund the bank’s contribution to the Provident Fund with interest thereof received by them at the time of retirement.
b) Contribute to the Pension Fund their share of 30% of the gap in the Pension Fund identified (Rs.934.95 crores)
5) The Bank Employees’ Pension Regulations, 1995 will be effective up to 31.3.2010 and cease to apply to any person appointed in the services of banks on or after 1.4.2010.
6) A defined contributory retirement benefit scheme governed as by the “contributory pension scheme introduced for employees of Central Government with effect from 1.1.2004” will be introduced for workmen/officers joining the services of banks on or after 1.4.2010. There shall be no separate contributory provident fund in respect of these workmen/officers.
7) The terms hereof will not be applicable to State Bank of India.

 

 

Part III : Views About Sharing of Burden on Account of Pension  

Please refer the above minutes of meeting held with IBA on 27.11.2009 wherein Point No. 1 (b) and 3 (b) clearly states the burden to be shared by the existing employees over and above the pathetic and effective increase of 7% achieved in the bipartite. All the bank unions viz AIBO, AIBOC, INBOC, NOBO etc. are currently being headed by retired leaders serving their own interest and it is difficult to find a union lead by serving officer/employee. We do not see any improvement in the current scenario until unless we retire and fall in the same group. In this way our leaders have assured that we do not receive any benefits as we may become complacent and stop running after them. Over and above, inflation during these years has gone up considerably:-

In comparison to the above and 50% hike given to Govt. Staff what we get after 5 years is mentioned below:
1) Wage revision - 7%
2) Arrears - out of which 30% to go to the pension fund and 4% levy to union
for there outstanding work.
3) Other benefits - depending on the bank.


This is not injustice but collective bargaining power without which we may have had a better pay revision. We should thank our leaders that they have not taken the no. of poor people in India into account before asking for sacrifice else we would have had a negative pay revision.

Moreover, if we are not able to rise to the occasion we should be prepared with n no. of begging bowls (n representing the no. of members in our family) without the help of which we may not be able to fulfill our familial responsibilities and provide them a decent standard of living. Further, there are few more steps provided by one of our colleagues at allbankingsolutions.com that can be undertaken in order to sustain with the current salary levels.

1. If you own a house, give it on rent and shift to near by slum. This way you will be able to increase your income. Some day your child may become slumdog Banker.
2. Apply for a BPL ration card. As per new manifesto you will get Wheat and Rice for Rs.2 or Rs.3 per KG whosoever makes the government.
3. Use Municipal Primary schools for the education of your children, if you cannot afford private and live in an affordable housing i.e.Jhuggi.
4. Use Primary healthcare centre for medical treatment.
5. Use Public conveyance on maximum occasions.
6. Take tuitions at home.
7. Look for alternate jobs if you are still eligible for other central/state Govt. jobs.
8. Purchase cloths from Jama Masjid market at cheap rate.
9. Buy vegetables when the whole community finishes purchasing. You will get vegetables at lower price.
10. Request management to rename you designations in accordance to your salary.
11. Mr.Venkatachalam will ensure that you follow all the above religiously .Some day Government will come out with some rehabilitation plan for Bankers i.e. waiver of Staff Overdraft, Staff Housing Loan, Vehicle Loan etc.


If we do not wish to or cannot undertake the above steps, we have the following alternatives:

1) Curse the system, union and management, sitting at home.
2) Pray to god.
3) Keep your hands on your heart and say all is well.
4) Wait for the final outcome and then take the Step 1.
5) Pray to union leaders.
6) Do gossip and politics on the subject like AIBOC i.e signing the accord with one hand and assuring the members with the other.
7) Say lal salaam and accept whatever treatment is meted out to us as a diehard communist.
8) Take action as an educated member. Use the power of your vote and subscription.

Please let us know if you take the most difficult yet effective step no. 8.

 

 

Comments :  Do you feel the above comments are biased ?  If so, you can send your views alongwith the facts to counter the same so that bankers can have the real factual position. However, the comments should not be of any personal nature or against a group.

You can submit your comments on : allbankingsolutions@gmail.com

 

Disclaimer : The views expressed here are the personal views of our readers and www.allbankingsolutions.com may not subscribe to such views.  The contents or data has not been verified / re-checked.  In case, any abuse is noticed, the same may be brought to our notice at allbankingsolutions@gmail.com so that we can review the same.